Menus
Soups
-
Mushroom Bisque
Wild mushroom blend, sherry, touch of cream
$6
-
Manhattan Clam Chowder
Local chopped clams with tomatoes, peppers, bacon, onions and potatoes
$7
gluten free
-
Hearty French Onion Soup
Three onion soup made with red onions, white onions and chives, baked with Gruyère, provolone and parmesan
$7
*Gluten Free upon request
gluten free
-
Chili
Fresh ground beef seasoned and slow cooked with red beans, onion, pepper and tomato, topped with cheddar and pepper jack cheese
$8
gluten free
Salads
-
The Wedge
Baby iceberg chopped bacon tomatoes red onions and blue cheese dressing, finished with crumbled Gorgonzola
$9
gluten free
-
Classic Spinach Salad
Baby organic spinach, bacon, red onions, fresh mushrooms and chopped hard boiled egg, tossed in a warm bacon vinaigrette
$10
gluten free
-
Chopped Salad
Iceberg lettuce with salami, provolone, mixed olives, cherry peppers, tomatoes and red onions, tossed in extra virgin olive oil and red wine vinegar, topped with homemade croutons
$11
*Gluten free upon request
gluten free
-
Add to Any Salad
Grilled Chicken $6
Grilled Shrimp $15
Salmon (Blackened or Grilled) $16
Grilled Sliced Steak $16
gluten free
Raw Bar
-
Tuna Tartare
Asian sesame style, served over diced avocado
$14
*Gluten free upon request
gluten free
-
Seasonal Oysters
On the half shell (6)
$16
gluten free
-
Middle Neck Clams
On the half shell (6)
$14
gluten free
-
Colossal Gulf Shrimp
Wild caught, served with cocktail sauce, lemon wedge and horseradish (3)
$15
gluten free
Signature Starters
-
Charcuterie for Two
Chefs selection of artisanal meats and cheeses, paired with traditional accompaniments
$17
*Gluten free upon request
gluten free
-
Drunken Clams
Middle neck clams steamed in garlic, beer and lime butter broth
$14
*Gluten free upon request
gluten free
-
Mediterranean Octopus
Marinated and grilled, served with mixed olives, lemon and capers
$16
gluten free
-
Steakhouse Bacon
Thick sliced applewood smoked bacon, finished with a maple bourbon glaze, served over citrus fennel slaw
$12
-
Sacchetti
Ricotta and parmesan stuffed pasta purses in a tomato blush vodka sauce, topped with crispy prosciutto
$14
-
Baked Oysters
Freshly shucked and stuffed with sautéed baby spinach, topped with Hollandaise and finished with grated parmesan reggiano (6)
$14
gluten free
-
Waterman’s Crab Cake
Colossal crab meat combined with onions, peppers, corn purée and corn bread, baked and served over avocado crema
$17
Chef Specialties
-
Grilled Pork Chop
Glazed with smoked peach and honey, served with mashed potatoes and charred asparagus
$29
gluten free
-
Frutti di Mare Fra Diavolo
Seared scallops, clams, jumbo shrimp and calamari, tossed with spicy tomato sauce, served over homemade linguine
$29
*Gluten free upon request
gluten free
-
Pomegranate Chicken
Roasted, semi-boneless, organic Bell & Evans Airline Chicken Breast, marinated with rosemary and fine herbs, glazed in a pomegranate reduction, sliced over brussel sprouts and au gratin potatoes
$26
gluten free
-
Bourbon Salmon
Organic, seared and glazed with maple sugar and Kentucky bourbon, topped with maple compound butter, served with roasted root vegetables
$28
-
Merlot Braised Short Rib
Boneless, slow braised in natural jus, served over mashed potatoes and drizzled with a red wine reduction
$34
gluten free
-
Long Island Duck Breast
Thyme infused and seared with an orange and cherry compote, served with roasted root vegetables
$32
gluten free
-
New Zealand Rack of Lamb
Grass fed, herb crusted, and pan seared with Demi-Glace, served with mashed potatoes and roasted root vegetables
$34
gluten free
-
Waterman’s Crab Cakes
Dual colossal crab cakes combined with onions, peppers, corn purée and corn bread, baked and served over avocado crema with roasted root vegetables
$29
-
North Atlantic Cod
Roasted with broccoli rabe, Idaho potatoes and white beans in a garlic broth
$27
gluten free
-
Grouper en Papillote
Grouper with shrimp, artichoke hearts, olives and sliced roasted potatoes, seasoned with garlic, herbs, white wine and butter, baked in parchment paper
$29
gluten free
-
Pasta of the Day
Chefs choice, homemade daily
$21
Signature Steaks
All Steaks garnished with a Demi-Glace Drizzle-
8 oz Filet Mignon 100% Grass Fed
Center cut, grilled and topped with Cabernet compound butter, served with mashed potatoes and vegetable of the day
$38
gluten free
-
18 oz Chateaubriand for Two 100% Grass Fed
Center cut Tenderloin, seared and sliced tableside, served with Mashed Potatoes and Vegetable of the Day
$88
gluten free
-
14 oz Prime NY Strip, Dry Aged 45 Days
“Steak Lovers Steak,” grilled to perfection, served with Waterman’s crispy steak fries and vegetable of the day
$45
gluten free
-
18 oz Bone in Ribeye C.A.B. Cowboy Steak, Dry Aged 45 Days
Seasoned and grilled, served with baked potato and vegetable of the day
$44
gluten free
Sauce Trio - $6
Please Select Three: or $2 Each-
Au Poivre
gluten free
-
Blue Cheese Demi
gluten free
-
Hollandaise
gluten free
-
Bearnaise
gluten free
-
Sautéed Onions and Mushrooms
gluten free
Accompaniments
-
4 oz Lobster Tail
$16
gluten free
-
Grilled Colossal Shrimp
$15
gluten free
Signature Sides to Share
-
Colossal Baked Potato
Sour cream, cheddar, chives and crumbled bacon
$6
gluten free
-
Brussels Sprouts
Bacon, onions and American honey bourbon glaze, served in a skillet
$8
gluten free
-
Classic Mashed Potatoes
Butter and a touch of cream, served in a skillet
$6
gluten free
-
Skillet Potato Medley Au Grain
Sweet and Idaho potatoes, baked with Swiss and parmesan
$8
gluten free
-
Grilled Asparagus
Topped with parmesan
$8
gluten free
-
Skillet Tavern Potatoes
Fried then sautéed with garlic, onions, hot cherry peppers and parmesan
$8
gluten free
-
Roasted Root Vegetables
Parsnips, sweet potatoes, carrots and celeriac
$6
gluten free
-
Waterman’s Crispy Steak Fries
Waterman’s Special seasoning with herbed chipotle aioli
$6
gluten free
Tavern Appetizers
-
Fried Calamari
Traditional style served with homemade marinara or tossed in sweet thai sesame chili sauce with hot cherry peppers
$14
gluten free
-
Wings
Tossed in your choice of buffalo, BBQ or sweet Thai sesame chile sauce
$11
gluten free
-
Chicken Tenders
Breaded and fried, served plain or tossed in your choice of buffalo, BBQ or sweet thai chile sesame sauce
$9
-
Deviled Eggs
Our twist on a classic favorite, just a hint of cayenne pepper, topped with maple sugar bacon
$9
-
Blackened Chicken Quesadilla
Grilled blackened chicken, cheddar cheese and pico de gallo, served with a side of sour cream
$12
gluten free
-
Mozzarella Sticks
Served with homemade marinara sauce
$9
-
Sweet Potato Waffle Fries
Served with maple syrup
$8
gluten free
-
Fried Ravioli
Served with homemade marinara sauce
$9
-
Mushroom Bangers
Stuffed with sweet italian sausage and seasoned bread crumbs, baked in a pernod cream sauce, served in a skillet
$11
-
Loaded Cheeseburger Eggroll
American cheese, onion, pickle, bacon and jalapeños, deep fried in a wonton wrapper
$11
-
Nachos
House fried tortilla chips, topped with cheddar cheese, pico de gallo, jalapeños and shredded lettuce, served with salsa and sour cream
$8
w/ chili $4
w/ grilled chicken $6
Tavern Specialties
-
Fish Tacos
Tempura battered atlantic cod, shaved lettuce and pico de gallo, served with Wasabi aioli on a soft corn taco shell and potato chips
$14
gluten free
-
Eggplant Rollatini
Egg battered and stuffed with ricotta cheese, baked with marinara and mozzarella, served over cavatappi pasta
$12
-
BBQ Chicken and Ribs
Roasted organic semi-boneless bell & evans chicken cutlet and house-smoked Baby back ribs braised with a tangy citrus BBQ sauce served with french fries
$17
gluten free
-
Thai Chili Pork Shanks
Braised and glazed, served with sweet potato fries
$17
gluten free
-
“Have A Ball”
One large burrata-stuffed meatball in homemade tomato gravy
$15
-
Short Rib Cheddar Mac and Cheese
Baked cheddar with cavatappi pasta, topped with seasoned bread crumbs and crumbled bacon
$17
-
Shepherd’s Pie
Seasoned ground beef with sherry, peas, corn, carrots and onions, topped with mashed potatoes and baked
$17
gluten free
Specialty Burgers
-
8oz Dry Aged Square Burger
Pat LaFrieda's signature | Choice of cheese on ciabatta bread, served with French fries
$15
*Must be prepared medium or higher
gluten free
-
Sliders
Sliders topped with caramelized onion and choice of cheese (3), served with french fries
$12
gluten free
-
10oz Angus Burger / Cheeseburger
Choice of Cheese, served with French Fries
$13
$14
Cheeses: American, Cheddar, Provolone, Mozzarella or Blue Cheese
gluten free
-
French Dip Burger
10oz Angus burger, topped with shaved prime rib, caramelized onions, swiss and provolone cheese, topped with a crispy fried onion ring, served on ciabatta with a side of au jus and french fries
$17
gluten free
-
Steakhouse Burger
10oz Angus burger, topped with mushrooms, cheddar cheese and thick-cut bacon, topped with a crispy fried onion ring, served with french fries
$16
gluten free
-
California Burger
10oz Angus burger, topped with crispy fried avocado, sliced lettuce, tomato and red onion, with truffle mayo, topped with a crispy fried onion ring, served with french fries
$17
gluten free
Signature Sandwiches
-
Tuscan Chicken
Grilled organic bell & evans chicken cutlet, broccoli rabe, melted mozzarella, roasted pepper coulis and pesto mayonnaise on ciabatta, served with potato chips
$16
gluten free
-
Tavern BLT
Thick sliced applewood smoked bacon, bibb lettuce and tomatoes, finished with a touch of mayonnaise on toasted sourdough, served with potato chips
$12
gluten free
-
Hand Carved Turkey Club
1/2 lb. House roasted turkey piled high, with bibb lettuce, tomatoes, and thick sliced applewood smoked bacon, finished with a touch of mayonnaise on toasted sourdough served with potato chips
$15
gluten free
-
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Crispy fried chicken breast, with lettuce and tomato on a bun, topped with chipotle mayo
$12
gluten free
From the Pizza Oven
-
Buffalo Chicken Bar Pie
12” bar pie, topped with fried buffalo chicken and cheddar cheese, over ranch dressing
$11
gluten free
-
Tavern Pie
Hand-tossed homemade pizza dough, with our savory tomato sauce, topped with a blend of mozzarella, provolone and parmesan
12” Pie $9
*Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust available / +$4)
16” Pie $14
Toppings
-
each $2
Pepperoni
Grilled Chicken
Shaved Ribeye
Ground Sausage
Anchovies
Salami
-
each $1
Onions
Bell Peppers
Cherry Peppers
Broccoli Rabe
Black Olives
Mushrooms