Menus

Mediterranean Octopus

Roasted and marinated, mixed olives, lemon, capers

$16

gluten free

Steakhouse Bacon

Thick sliced applewood smoked bacon, maple bourbon glaze, citrus fennel slaw

$12

Mushroom Bangers

Mushrooms, stuffed with sweet Italian sausage and seasoned bread crumbs, Pernod cream sauce

$14

Waterman’s Crab Cake

Baked colossal crab meat, onions, peppers, corn purée, cornbread, grain mustard sauce, mango salsa

$17

Fried Calamari

Traditional style, choice of homemade marinara or tossed in sweet Thai sesame chili sauce with hot cherry peppers

$12

*Gluten free upon request

Fried Ravioli

Homemade marinara sauce

$10

Wings

Choice of buffalo, BBQ, or sweet Thai sesame chili sauce

$11

gluten free

Baked Oysters

Freshly shucked and stuffed, sautéed baby spinach, hollandaise, grated Parmigiano-Reggiano

(6) $14

gluten free

Drunken Clams

Middle neck clams, garlic, white wine butter broth, crostini

$14

*Gluten free upon request

Manhattan Clam Chowder

Local chopped clams, tomatoes, peppers, bacon, onions, potatoes

$7

gluten free

Butternut Squash

Butternut squash, candied walnuts

$7

gluten free

Hearty French Onion Soup

Red onions, white onions, chives, gruyère, provolone, parmesan

$7

*Gluten free upon request

The Wedge

Baby iceberg, chopped bacon, tomatoes, red onions, blue cheese dressing, crumbled gorgonzola

$11

gluten free

Classic Caesar

Romaine, shaved parmesan, homemade croutons, creamy caesar dressing

$11

*Gluten free upon request

Spinach Salad

Organic baby spinach, bacon, red onions, fresh mushrooms, chopped hard-boiled egg, warm bacon vinaigrette

$11

gluten free

Chopped Salad

Iceberg lettuce, salami, provolone, mixed olives, hot cherry peppers, tomatoes, red onions, extra virgin olive oil, red wine vinegar, homemade croutons

$13

*Gluten free upon request

spicy

Add to Any Salad

Grilled chicken $5

Grilled shrimp $11

Salmon (blackened or grilled) $11

gluten free

Bourbon Salmon

Organic, seared and glazed with maple sugar and Kentucky bourbon, maple compound butter topping, roasted root vegetables

$28

Merlot Braised Short Rib

Boneless, slow-braised in natural jus, mashed potatoes, red wine reduction, roasted root vegetables

$34

gluten free

Waterman’s Crab Cakes

Baked dual colossal crab cakes, onions, peppers, corn purée, cornbread, grain mustard sauce, mango salsa, roasted root vegetables

$29

Lemon-Thyme Chicken

Boneless Bell & Evans Chicken Breast, lemon-thyme butter sauce, mashed potatoes, broccolini

$26

*Gluten free upon request

New Zealand Rack of Lamb

Grass fed, herb crusted, pan seared, demi-glace, mashed potatoes, roasted root vegetables

$34

gluten free

Murphy Pork Chop

Seared bon-in chop, onions, peppers, hot cheery peppers, garlic white wine sauce, crispy hand-cut potatoes

$29

gluten free

North Atlantic Cod

Roasted, broccoli rabe, Idaho potatoes, white beans, garlic broth

$27

Sacchetti

Ricotta and parmesan stuffed pasta purses, tomato blush vodka sauce, crispy prosciutto

$21

Gnocchi Pesto Cream

Homemade gnocchi, basil pesto cream sauce

$21

*Contains pine nuts

Add grilled chicken + $5

Add grilled shrimp + $11

Shrimp and Asparagus Risotto

Four (4) large marinated and grilled shrimp, asparagus risotto, fried fennel

*Gluten free upon request $27

Seafood Paella

Shrimp, scallops, clams, smoked chicken, chorizo, saffron risotto, onions, peppers, sofrito

$32

gluten free

Filet Mignon

8 oz center cut, grilled, cabernet compound butter topping, mashed potatoes, roasted root vegetables

$36

gluten free

NY Strip

14oz Dry Aged 45 Days, “Steak Lovers Steak”, grilled to perfection, mashed potatoes, broccolini

$45

gluten free

Bone in Ribeye

18 oz C.A.B. Cowboy Steak, Dry Aged 28 Days seasoned, grilled, mashed potatoes, roasted root vegetables

$42

gluten free

Signature 8 oz Dry Aged Burger

Choice of cheese, ciabatta bread, French fries

$15

*Gluten free upon request

*Must be prepared medium or higher

10 oz Angus Burger | Cheeseburger

Choice of cheese, French fries

$13

Cheeseburger $14

*Gluten free upon request

French Dip Burger

10oz Angus burger, shaved prime rib, caramelized onions, Swiss and provolone cheese, crispy fried, onion ring, ciabatta, au jus, French fries

$17

*Gluten free upon request

Steakhouse Burger

10 oz Angus burger, mushrooms, cheddar cheese, thick-sliced bacon, crispy fried onion ring, French fries

$16

*Gluten free upon request

California Burger

10 oz Angus burger, crispy fried avocado, lettuce, tomato, red onion, crispy fried onion ring, French fries, side of chipotle mayo

$17

*Gluten free upon request

Cheeses

American | Cheddar | Provolone | Mozzarella | Blue Cheese

El Diablo Pie

Homemade spicy habanero salsa, potatoes, chorizo, roasted red peppers, crème fraîche

12" Pie $12

16" Pie $16

*Gluten free upon request

spicy

Margherita Pie

Diced tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil

12" Pie $10

16" Pie $14

*Gluten free upon request

Baked Cavatappi Pie

Baked cavatappi pasta, blush tomato sauce, crispy prosciutto

12" Pie $11

16" Pie $15

*Gluten free upon request

Tavern Pie

Hand tossed, homemade pizza dough, savory tomato sauce, mozzarella, provolone, parmesan

12" Pie $8

16" Pie $12

Toppings

Onions | Bell Peppers | Hot Cherry Peppers | Broccoli Rabe | Mushrooms each + $1

Pepperoni | Grilled Chicken | Shaved Ribeye | Ground Sausage | Salami each + $2

Shrimp Cocktail

(4) shrimp, cocktail sauce

$15

gluten free

Middle Neck Clams

(6) on the ½ shell

$12

gluten free

Seasonal Oysters

(6) on the ½ shell

$16

gluten free

Short Rib Cheddar Mac and Cheese

Cavatappi pasta, cheddar cheese, bread crumbs, crumbled bacon

$17

Organic Tuscan Chicken

Grilled Bell & Evans Chicken Cutlet, broccoli rabe, melted mozzarella, roasted pepper coulis, pesto mayonnaise, ciabatta, potato chips

$16

*Gluten free upon request

Tavern BLT

Thick sliced Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise, toasted sourdough, potato chips

$14

*Gluten free upon request

Fried Chicken Wrap

Crispy fried chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, chipotle mayo, potato chips

$12

*Gluten free upon request

Eggplant Rollatini

Egg battered, stuffed with ricotta cheese, baked with marinara and mozzarella, cavatappi pasta

$15

Lobster and Shrimp Quesadilla

Bayou seasoned, lobster, shrimp, shredded jack and cheddar cheese blend, corn, peppers, flour tortilla

$15

*Gluten free upon request

Thai Chili Pork Shanks

Braised and glazed, sweet potato waffle fries

$16

gluten free

Short Rib Grilled Cheese

Slow braised short rib, provolone and American cheese, sourdough, French fries

$14

Cuban Sandwich

Slow roasted pork, smoked ham, swiss cheese, pickles, mustard, Cuban roll, potato chips

$16

Baked Potato

Sour cream, chives

$5

gluten free

Roasted Root Vegetables

Parsnips, sweet potatoes, carrots, celeriac

$6

gluten free

Brussel Sprouts

Bacon, onions, American honey bourbon glaze, served in a skillet

$8

gluten free

Broccolini

Garlic and oil, touch of lemon

$6

gluten free

Waterman’s Crispy Steak Fries

Waterman’s special seasoning, herbed chipotle aioli

$6

gluten free

Sweet Potato Waffle Fries

Sprinkled with sea salt and cinnamon sugar

$8

gluten free

Risotto Du Jour

Daily selection of Risotto

$8

gluten free

Mozzarella Sticks

Served with French fries

$8

Grilled Cheese

White toast, American cheese, French fries

$8

Chicken Fingers

Served with French fries

$8

Cavatappi Marinara

Cavatappi pasta, marinara

$8